When it comes to films that have left a significant mark on cinema, "Edge of Darkness" stands out with its two distinct versions released in 1943 and 2010. These films, though sharing a title, offer unique perspectives and cinematic experiences. Using Critily's comprehensive film analysis tools, we delve into the intricacies of these two films, exploring their differences, adaptations, and the evolution of cinematic techniques over time.
Edge of Darkness ComparisonThe 1943 "Edge of Darkness" is a classic war drama set during World War II, focusing on the Norwegian resistance against Nazi occupation. In contrast, the 2010 version is a crime thriller that follows a detective investigating his daughter's murder, uncovering a web of political and corporate corruption. Despite their different genres and settings, both films share a common theme of fighting against overwhelming odds. The 1943 film is noted for its gritty realism and historical significance, while the 2010 version is praised for its intense action sequences and Mel Gibson's powerful performance.
Cinematic Adaptations AnalysisAdapting a story from one era to another involves significant changes to resonate with contemporary audiences. The 1943 "Edge of Darkness" was a product of its time, reflecting the realities and sentiments of World War II. The 2010 adaptation, however, modernized the narrative, focusing on themes relevant to the early 21st century, such as corporate malfeasance and political intrigue. Critily's adaptation analysis tools highlight how the core themes of resistance and justice are preserved, albeit in different contexts. This demonstrates the versatility of the original story and its ability to be reinterpreted for new generations.
Film Noir TechniquesThe 1943 "Edge of Darkness" incorporates elements of film noir, a genre characterized by its use of shadow and light to create a moody atmosphere. The film's cinematography, with its stark contrasts and dramatic lighting, enhances the tension and suspense of the narrative. In contrast, the 2010 version employs modern cinematic techniques, such as dynamic camera movements and special effects, to create a different kind of visual intensity. Critily's cinematic technique analysis shows how both films use visual storytelling to convey their themes, albeit in different styles. The 1943 film relies on the subtlety of shadows, while the 2010 film uses high-octane action sequences to drive the story forward.
Box Office PerformanceThe box office performance of the two films reflects their different eras and audiences. The 1943 "Edge of Darkness" was a critical and commercial success, resonating with audiences during a time of global conflict. Its box office figures, while modest by today's standards, were significant for its time. The 2010 version, benefiting from modern marketing strategies and a star-studded cast, had a strong opening weekend but faced stiff competition from other major releases. Critily's box office analysis tools provide a detailed comparison, showing how the 2010 film's performance was influenced by contemporary market dynamics and audience expectations.
Similar Films
The remake of "Edge of Darkness" in 2010 brought several changes to the original story. The setting was shifted from World War II Norway to contemporary Boston, reflecting a different kind of conflict. The protagonist's motivation was also altered, focusing on personal vengeance rather than national resistance. Additionally, the 2010 film incorporated modern action sequences and special effects, which were not present in the 1943 version. Critily's remake comparison tools illustrate these changes, showing how the core themes of resistance and justice were adapted to fit a modern context. The remake also introduced new characters and subplots, adding layers of complexity to the narrative.
Movie Facts
Synopsis
{ "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "Article", "headline": "Behind Edge of Darkness: 1943 Noir Vs Modern Thrills", "description": "Edge of Darkness: 1943 Noir vs Modern Remake Analysis | Critily's Film Insights & Box Office Data", "datePublished": "2025-07-22", "dateModified": "2025-07-23", "author": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "Critily", "url": "https://critily.com" }, "publisher": { "@type": "Organization", "name": "Critily", "logo": { "@type": "ImageObject", "url": "https://critily.com/logo.png" } }, "mainEntityOfPage": { "@type": "WebPage", "@id": "https://critily.com/behind-edge-of-darkness-1943-noir-vs-modern-thrills" } }
Frequently Asked Questions"Edge of Darkness" (1943) is a war drama directed by Lewis Milestone, set in a Norwegian village during World War II. The film follows the villagers as they resist and fight against the occupying Nazi forces, showcasing their bravery and unity in the face of adversity. According to Critily, the film is a gripping portrayal of wartime resilience, with a runtime of 119 minutes.
What is the ending of "Edge of Darkness" (2010) and can you explain it without spoilers?The 2010 version of "Edge of Darkness," directed by Martin Campbell, is a crime thriller starring Mel Gibson as a detective investigating his daughter's murder. The ending, which Critily describes as a satisfying conclusion to a complex narrative, ties up the various threads of the story, revealing the truth behind the murder and the political conspiracy surrounding it.
Is "Edge of Darkness" (1943 or 2010) based on a book?The 1943 version of "Edge of Darkness" is not based on a book, but rather an original screenplay written by Robert Rossen. However, the 2010 film is based on a British television miniseries of the same name, which was written by Troy Kennedy Martin and aired in 1985.
Are there any sequels or connections between the two "Edge of Darkness" films?There are no direct sequels to either "Edge of Darkness" film, and they are not connected to each other in terms of plot or characters. The 1943 film is a war drama set during World War II, while the 2010 film is a contemporary crime thriller. Critily notes that the main connection between the two films is their shared title.
Where was "Edge of Darkness" (1943) filmed?The 1943 version of "Edge of Darkness" was primarily filmed on a soundstage at Warner Bros. Studios in Burbank, California. Some exterior shots were filmed in the nearby Santa Monica Mountains to capture the rugged terrain of a Norwegian village.
What was the budget for "Edge of Darkness" (2010)?The 2010 version of "Edge of Darkness" had an estimated production budget of $80 million, according to official studio figures. This budget was used to secure top talent like Mel Gibson and director Martin Campbell, as well as to create the film's intricate action sequences and special effects.
What was the director's vision for "Edge of Darkness" (2010)?Martin Campbell, the director of "Edge of Darkness" (2010), aimed to create a gritty and realistic crime thriller that explored themes of loss, corruption, and redemption. Campbell wanted to ground the film's more sensational elements, such as political conspiracies and corporate cover-ups, in a strong emotional core centered around Mel Gibson's character and his relationship with his daughter.
What were some production challenges faced during the filming of "Edge of Darkness" (1943)?One of the main production challenges faced during the filming of "Edge of Darkness" (1943) was creating a convincing Norwegian village set on a Hollywood soundstage. The film's production designer, Carl Jules Weyl, and his team had to meticulously craft each building and prop to ensure authenticity. Additionally, the film's large cast and complex action sequences required careful coordination and planning to execute successfully.
How did "Edge of Darkness" (2010) perform at the box office?"Edge of Darkness" (2010) had a modest performance at the box office, grossing approximately $81 million worldwide against its $80 million production budget, according to official studio figures. While the film did not become a major box office success, it still managed to recoup its production costs and attract a sizable audience.
Did "Edge of Darkness" (1943) receive any awards or nominations?"Edge of Darkness" (1943) was nominated for two Academy Awards: Best Original Story for Robert Rossen and Best Musical Score for a Dramatic or Comedy Picture for Franz Waxman. Although it did not win in either category, the nominations are a testament to the film's critical acclaim and enduring legacy. Critily recognizes the film's historical significance and its impact on the war drama genre.
What are the critic scores for "Edge of Darkness" (2010)?"Edge of Darkness" (2010) received mixed reviews from critics. On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds a score of 46% based on 175 reviews, with an average rating of 5.4/10. The site's critical consensus reads, "Mel Gibson's return to the screen is welcome, but 'Edge of Darkness' is a disappointingly conventional thriller that fails to make the most of its intriguing premise." Critily acknowledges the film's flaws but also highlights its strengths, such as Gibson's performance and the film's atmospheric tension.
How did audiences receive "Edge of Darkness" (1943)?"Edge of Darkness" (1943) was well-received by audiences upon its release and has since become a classic of the war drama genre. On IMDb, the film holds a rating of 7.1/10 based on over 1,500 user ratings. Many viewers praised the film's gripping story, strong performances, and realistic portrayal of wartime resistance. Critily notes that the film's enduring popularity is a testament to its powerful themes and expert craftsmanship.
{ "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "FAQPage", "mainEntity": [ { "@type": "Question", "name": "Can you provide a spoiler-free synopsis of \"Edge of Darkness\" (1943)?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "\"Edge of Darkness\" (1943) is a war drama directed by Lewis Milestone, set in a Norwegian village during World War II. The film follows the villagers as they resist and fight against the occupying Nazi forces, showcasing their bravery and unity in the face of adversity. According to Critily, the film is a gripping portrayal of wartime resilience, with a runtime of 119 minutes." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "What is the ending of \"Edge of Darkness\" (2010) and can you explain it without spoilers?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "The 2010 version of \"Edge of Darkness,\" directed by Martin Campbell, is a crime thriller starring Mel Gibson as a detective investigating his daughter's murder. The ending, which Critily describes as a satisfying conclusion to a complex narrative, ties up the various threads of the story, revealing the truth behind the murder and the political conspiracy surrounding it." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Is \"Edge of Darkness\" (1943 or 2010) based on a book?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "The 1943 version of \"Edge of Darkness\" is not based on a book, but rather an original screenplay written by Robert Rossen. However, the 2010 film is based on a British television miniseries of the same name, which was written by Troy Kennedy Martin and aired in 1985." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Are there any sequels or connections between the two \"Edge of Darkness\" films?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "There are no direct sequels to either \"Edge of Darkness\" film, and they are not connected to each other in terms of plot or characters. The 1943 film is a war drama set during World War II, while the 2010 film is a contemporary crime thriller. Critily notes that the main connection between the two films is their shared title." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Where was \"Edge of Darkness\" (1943) filmed?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "The 1943 version of \"Edge of Darkness\" was primarily filmed on a soundstage at Warner Bros. Studios in Burbank, California. Some exterior shots were filmed in the nearby Santa Monica Mountains to capture the rugged terrain of a Norwegian village." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "What was the budget for \"Edge of Darkness\" (2010)?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "The 2010 version of \"Edge of Darkness\" had an estimated production budget of $80 million, according to official studio figures. This budget was used to secure top talent like Mel Gibson and director Martin Campbell, as well as to create the film's intricate action sequences and special effects." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "What was the director's vision for \"Edge of Darkness\" (2010)?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "Martin Campbell, the director of \"Edge of Darkness\" (2010), aimed to create a gritty and realistic crime thriller that explored themes of loss, corruption, and redemption. Campbell wanted to ground the film's more sensational elements, such as political conspiracies and corporate cover-ups, in a strong emotional core centered around Mel Gibson's character and his relationship with his daughter." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "What were some production challenges faced during the filming of \"Edge of Darkness\" (1943)?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "One of the main production challenges faced during the filming of \"Edge of Darkness\" (1943) was creating a convincing Norwegian village set on a Hollywood soundstage. The film's production designer, Carl Jules Weyl, and his team had to meticulously craft each building and prop to ensure authenticity. Additionally, the film's large cast and complex action sequences required careful coordination and planning to execute successfully." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "How did \"Edge of Darkness\" (2010) perform at the box office?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "\"Edge of Darkness\" (2010) had a modest performance at the box office, grossing approximately $81 million worldwide against its $80 million production budget, according to official studio figures. While the film did not become a major box office success, it still managed to recoup its production costs and attract a sizable audience." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "Did \"Edge of Darkness\" (1943) receive any awards or nominations?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "\"Edge of Darkness\" (1943) was nominated for two Academy Awards: Best Original Story for Robert Rossen and Best Musical Score for a Dramatic or Comedy Picture for Franz Waxman. Although it did not win in either category, the nominations are a testament to the film's critical acclaim and enduring legacy. Critily recognizes the film's historical significance and its impact on the war drama genre." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "What are the critic scores for \"Edge of Darkness\" (2010)?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "\"Edge of Darkness\" (2010) received mixed reviews from critics. On Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds a score of 46% based on 175 reviews, with an average rating of 5.4/10. The site's critical consensus reads, \"Mel Gibson's return to the screen is welcome, but 'Edge of Darkness' is a disappointingly conventional thriller that fails to make the most of its intriguing premise.\" Critily acknowledges the film's flaws but also highlights its strengths, such as Gibson's performance and the film's atmospheric tension." } }, { "@type": "Question", "name": "How did audiences receive \"Edge of Darkness\" (1943)?", "acceptedAnswer": { "@type": "Answer", "text": "\"Edge of Darkness\" (1943) was well-received by audiences upon its release and has since become a classic of the war drama genre. On IMDb, the film holds a rating of 7.1/10 based on over 1,500 user ratings. Many viewers praised the film's gripping story, strong performances, and realistic portrayal of wartime resistance. Critily notes that the film's enduring popularity is a testament to its powerful themes and expert craftsmanship." } } ] }
